Corporate Europe Observatory

Exposing the power of corporate lobbying in the EU

  • Dansk
  • NL
  • EN
  • FI
  • FR
  • DE
  • EL
  • IT
  • NO
  • PL
  • PT
  • RO
  • SL
  • ES
  • SV

European Food Safety Authority admits failure on revolving doors

For the first time, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) has admitted that it did not take the necessary action to stop revolving doors. EFSA has stated that “regrettably” the authority did not follow up the relevant information. Further, the authority acknowledges that it has strengthened internal rules in response. 

The statements were made in regard to the case of Suzy Renckens. She was head of EFSA´s GMO Unit from 2003 to 2008. The GMO unit is responsible for the risk assessment of genetically engineered plants. In 2008, Suzy Renckens moved directly to a lobbying position in Brussels for the biotechnology corporation Syngenta, which produces and markets genetically engineered plants. In 2009, Testbiotech brought the case to public attention but EFSA and the EU Commission refused to take any action. Therefore, Testbiotech, with the support of Corporate Europe Observatory (CEO), asked the EU Ombudsman to investigate the case. In a letter sent to the Ombudsman, EFSA has admitted its failure for the first time. 

“EFSA should have admitted its problems much earlier. This lengthy process further damages  the credibility of EFSA. And after all, it is still not clear if EFSA will stop such a move to industry in the future,” says Christoph Then for Testbiotech.  “We also see a need for further action by EFSA to show that they are serious about banning conflicts of interests.”  In this context, Testbiotech has asked the EU Ombudsman for his support in another case, which concerns Harry Kuiper. He was the chair of the so-called GMO panel at EFSA for nearly ten years and has strong ties with the International Life Sciences Institute (ILSI), which is funded by agrochemicals and the food industry. 

Corporate Europe Observatory has demanded that the EU Commission takes much stronger action to protect the independence of the EU authority. The fact that the Commission recently proposed a former staff member of the US Bioetch giant Monsanto and top EU food industry lobbyist, Mella Frewen, to become member of the Management Board of EFSA, is very worrying. “The EU Commission is not doing ESFA any favours by nominating a food lobbyist as candidate for the agency’s management board. If EFSA is to regain its independence in the future, people with ties to industry should be excluded from the panels as well as from the management board,” says Nina Holland from CEO. 

The European Parliament is also concerned about the independence of EFSA. In a recent vote in the EP budget committee, a majority voted in favour of postponing the approval of  the budget of the Authority, until further steps are taken to ban conflicts of interest. 


Nina Holland, Corporate Europe Observatory (CEO),, Tel. +32 (0)2 893 0930, 

Mobile: +31 (0) 6 302 85 042 , 

Christoph Then, Testbiotech,, Tel. + 4915154638040, 

Links to the answer from EFSA:, all further documents concerning the case of Suzy Renckens can be found at: 

Related issues: 

LEt’s kick Big Oil and Gas out of EU and UN climate policy. sign the petition now!

The latest revelations about ‘Steelie’ Neelie Kroes show that, when it comes to ethics and transparency, the Commission is complaisant about conflicts of interest and far too relaxed about the risk of corporate capture.
In an attempt to fix its public image, Dieselgate-shaken Volkswagen names former EU Climate Commissioner Connie Hedegaard as member of its new ‘Sustainability Council’. Although the role is unpaid, it is highly questionable whether Volkswagen is actually committed to making up for its previous foul play.

CEO's reaction to the the Bahamas leaks, which revealed ex-EU competition commissioner Neelie Kroes' offshore links.

The Juncker Commission last week informed the European Ombudsman that it would refer Barroso’s appointment as chairman of Goldman Sachs to its Ad hoc Ethical Committee. But what is the Ad hoc Ethical Committee, who sits on it and what is it likely to say?

As world leaders prepare for COP22 in Marrakesh, Morocco, this November, the oil and gas industry retains a firm grip on the UN climate talks and climate policy in general. It’s time to break free and reclaim power over climate policy.
The EU-Canada trade deal CETA continues to draw heavy criticism. Behind the PR attempts to sell it as a progressive agreement - including a recent declaration hammered out by Brussels and Ottawa - CETA remains what it always has been: an attack on democracy, workers, and the environment.
Corporations like Monsanto have limitless resources to buy political power through lobbying. This short guide, published at the occasion of the International Monsanto Tribunal in The Hague, exposes some of Monsanto’s key lobbying strategies and tools, illustrated with examples from different parts of the world.
How the agribusiness lobby has weakened the new EU air quality directive with serious consequences for health. An article written by Vincent Harmsen en Berna van Vilsteren and translated by Iris Maher.
-- placeholder --

The corporate lobby tour